| 2026 | Sydney Wagner | Liberty Christian | TBD |
| 2026 | Caleb Shipley | Frankton | TBD |
| 2025 | Austin Perny | Pendleton | Indiana University Bloomington |
| 2025 | Jaylin Hernandez | Anderson | Purdue University |
| 2024 | Camille Yancey | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2024 | Seth Chester | Alexandria-Monroe | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2023 | Vanessa McNeal | Anderson Preparatory Academy | Butler University |
| 2023 | Ryan Mason | Anderson High School | Purdue University |
| 2022 | Tommy Manning | Lapel | Depauw University |
| 2022 | Grace McKinney | Pendleton | Depauw University |
| 2021 | Jack Hudson | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2021 | Hannah Gates | Pendleton | Indiana State University |
| 2020 | Isabel Taylor | Pendleton | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2020 | Anna Childers | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2019 | Megan Green | Pendleton | University of Notre Dame |
| 2019 | Connor Dunn | Pendleton | Purdue University |
| 2018 | Samantha Davis | Pendleton | Purdue University |
| 2018 | Kate Cowger | Pendleton | DePauw University |
| 2017 | Sarah Theohares | Pendleton | Indiana University-Bloomington |
| 2017 | Allison McCarty | Pendleton | Indiana University-Bloomington |
| 2016 | Derek Sims | Elwood | Butler University |
| 2016 | Brandon Boynton | Pendleton | IUPUI |
| 2015 | Noah Long | APA | DePauw University |
| 2015 | Robert Brenner | Alexandria-Monroe | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 2014 | Madicyn Hinton | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2014 | Emily Gaffney | Elwood | IUPUI |
| 2013 | Mr. Philip Horstmeyer | Lapel | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2013 | Ms. Anna Dudley | Pendleton | Marian University |
| 2012 | Ms. Cecily Swinford | Elwood | University of Notre Dame |
| 2012 | Ms. Abbie Haffner | Pendleton | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2011 | Mr. Devon Custer | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2011 | Ms. Leah Steele | Lapel | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2010 | Mr. Sam Foust | Lapel | Butler University |
| 2010 | Ms. Kaedra Hall | Highland | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| 2009 | Mr. Joshua A. Stephenson | Highland | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2009 | Ms. Jesica H. Brenner | Alexandria-Monroe | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2008 | Ms. Samantha Tarlton | Lapel | Hanover College |
| 2008 | Ms. Erica D. Couch | Anderson | Butler University |
| 2007 | Ms. Lynszy K. Stover | Elwood | Butler University |
| 2007 | Mr. Drake J. Sayre | Alexandria-Monroe | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2006 | Mr. Chase M. Carroll | Anderson | Butler University |
| 2006 | Ms. Sarah M. Beckerman | Anderson | Butler University |
| 2005 | Ms Diana C. Mui | Anderson | Valparaiso University |
| 2005 | Mr. Korey A. Lemond | Pendleton | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2004 | Ms. Elizabeth F. Schnepp Valentine | Pendleton | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2004 | Ms. Rachel E. Lakes | Pendleton | Deceased- Eponymous scholarship established in memorium |
| 2004 | Ms. Amanda N. Hackney | Anderson | Anderson University |
| 2004 | Mr. Logan J. Garner | Alexandria-Monroe | Butler University |
| 2004 | Ms. Melissa D. Emond Hunt | Pendleton | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2004 | Mr. Christopher I. Douglas | Lapel | Anderson University |
| 2003 | Mr. Chad D. Zook | Anderson | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2003 | Ms. Ashley N. Stanley Lloyd | Anderson | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2003 | Ms. Lindsey A. Hummel | Pendleton | Anderson University |
| 2003 | Ms. Kinsey L. Heberling | Highland | Hanover College |
| 2003 | Mr. Andrew R. Embry | Alexandria-Monroe | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 2003 | Mr. Travis M. Caples | Anderson | Anderson University |
| 2002 | Ms. Lyndsy A. Whetsel | Elwood | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 2002 | Mr. Anthony D. Stone | Lapel | University of Indianapolis |
| 2002 | Mr. Eric Reyes | Anderson | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2002 | Ms. Jennifer K. Hertzinger | Anderson | Anderson University |
| 2002 | Ms. Amy J. (Hartzell) Price | Highland | Anderson University |
| 2002 | Ms. Sarah L. Hartley | Elwood | DePauw University |
| 2001 | Ms. Melissa A. McGonigle Heffelfinger | Anderson | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2001 | Ms. Kristy L. Guthrie | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2001 | Mr. Patrick R. Ford | Pendleton | Purdue University - West Lafayette |
| 2001 | Mr. Gregory A. Durm | Elwood | University of Notre Dame |
| 2001 | Mr. Bijel K. Doshi | Anderson | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 2001 | Mrs. Jessica Carey DeShong | Pendleton | Indiana University - IUPUI |
| 2000 | Ms. Sarah J. Wilson | Pendleton | Butler University |
| 2000 | Mrs. Jamie L. Erskine Koontz | Alexandria-Monroe | Anderson University |
| 2000 | Mr. Dustin L. Collins | Elwood | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 2000 | Mr. Anthony D. Bergstrom | Highland | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 1999 | Ms. Jeanna M. Palmer | Highland | University of Notre Dame |
| 1999 | Mr. Daniel J. Lustig | Alexandria-Monroe | University of Notre Dame |
| 1999 | Ms. Elizabeth H. Kuhn | Indiana Academy | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| 1999 | Ms. Kristin L. Baranack | Alexandria-Monroe | University of Notre Dame |
| 1998 | Mr. Phillip J. Miller | Elwood | Ball State University |
| 1998 | Mr. Jason Isenburg | Alexandria-Monroe | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
